In e-commerce, understanding Lifetime Value (LTV) is critical. It’s the cornerstone of growth strategies, helping brands allocate resources effectively, optimize customer acquisition costs (CAC), and prioritize retention.
​

Yet, many brands still rely on oversimplified formulas like:

LTV = Average Order Value (AOV) × Order Frequency × Lifespan

While this formula seems straightforward, it often fails to capture the dynamic nature of customer behavior.

Enter cohort analysis—a more robust and insightful approach to calculating LTV. Here’s why it stands out.

While the AOV formula provides a quick estimation, it oversimplifies the complexities of e-commerce customer behavior.

Here's how Shopify explains it -

When it comes to customer lifespan, it’s important to understand the difference between being a contractual and non-contractual business.

Most online stores are non-contractual, meaning that once a purchase is made, the transaction is effectively over. The difficulty with these types of businesses is in identifying when an active customer (someone who makes purchases and will continue to make purchases) becomes an inactive customer (someone who will never make a purchase from your business again).

However, some online stores fall into the contractual category. With a contractual business, you know exactly when a customer becomes inactive because they announce it when they end their contract or subscription. With a contractual business, it’s much easier to identify your average customer lifespan.

Also, Here’s why the equation falls short:

1. Assumes Homogeneous Behavior

This method assumes all customers behave similarly over time. But in reality, customer behavior varies based on acquisition channels, timing, and purchasing habits.

2. Ignores Retention Decay

Customer retention isn’t linear. Most brands experience a steep drop-off in activity after the first purchase. The AOV formula fails to account for this.

3. Relies on Arbitrary Lifespan Estimates

Defining a customer’s lifespan often involves guesswork, leading to inaccurate projections.

4. Lacks Actionable Insights

While this formula gives a number, it doesn’t explain why certain customers are more valuable or how to improve retention.

Cohort analysis segments customers based on their acquisition date, allowing brands to track LTV over time. It’s rooted in actual customer data, not assumptions, making it far more reliable. Here’s how it addresses the pitfalls of the traditional formula:

1. Tracks Real Behavior Over Time

By grouping customers into cohorts (e.g., customers acquired in January), you can monitor their spending habits month by month, revealing trends in retention and engagement.

2. Accounts for Retention Decay

Cohort analysis inherently captures churn rates, showing how customer value evolves. This allows brands to predict LTV based on real retention patterns.

3. Provides Granular Insights

You can identify which cohorts perform best, which acquisition channels drive high-value customers, and which products boost retention.

4. Improves Decision-Making

With detailed insights, you can tailor marketing strategies, adjust product offerings, and refine customer experiences to maximize LTV.

​

Example: Comparing the Two Methods

Let’s say your e-commerce store acquires 1,000 customers in January. Using the traditional formula:

• AOV: $50

• Order Frequency: 2 orders/year

• Lifespan: 2 years

LTV = $50 × 2 × 2 = $200

Now, using cohort analysis, you might discover that:

• Only 40% of customers make a second purchase.

• The average spend of retained customers is $75 in the first year but drops to $30 in the second year.

This reveals a more nuanced picture, where the true LTV is closer to $150, not $200.

​

Why This Matters

For growing e-commerce brands, overestimating LTV can lead to poor decision-making. For example, you might overspend on customer acquisition, thinking customers will generate more revenue than they actually will. Cohort analysis mitigates this risk by grounding LTV calculations in real-world data.
​

How to Implement Cohort-Based LTV Analysis

Here’s how you can get started:

1. Segment Customers by Acquisition Date

Use your analytics platform to group customers by the month or week they first purchased.

2. Track Revenue Over Time

Monitor how much each cohort spends in subsequent months.

3. Visualize Retention Trends

Plot cohort performance on a graph to identify drop-offs and trends.

4. Iterate and Optimize

Use insights to test new retention strategies and track their impact on LTV.

​

Final Thoughts

Cohort analysis isn’t just a better way to calculate LTV—it’s a game-changer for e-commerce growth. By embracing this approach, you’ll gain deeper insights into customer behavior, enabling smarter decisions and sustainable growth.

Stop relying on outdated formulas. Switch to cohort analysis and unlock the full potential of your e-commerce brand. Explore Datadrew's powerful tool for LTV cohort analysis - https://apps.shopify.com/customer-lifetime-value